Letters to the Editor

Foreign Judges have nothing to lose

Sir - Mr. Francis Macgregor may have for the last 30 years been a member of the Central Committee of the ruling party and as speaker of the National Assembly - he may have shown affiliation with the members of the Central Committee of S.P.P.F.

Since Mr. Macgregor resigned from the S.P.P.F Central Committee and has accepted his appointment as President of the Country’s highest court, the Court of Appeal, I personally doubt that Mr. Macgregor at the age of 57 would want to render any favour to any former members of his former party.  He has nothing to lose should he wish to remain impartial as the President of the Court of Appeal.

Let us face the facts.  Foreign Judges have nothing to lose if their judgment lacks the impartiality that is required from the judiciary, for the simple reason that they came here and will be leaving at the end of their term. Whereas for Seychellois Judges they have much to lose if impartiality in their judgment is lacking as they are here to stay and they would have to face the people of Seychelles, for any of their wrong doings.

When I filed a civil appeal against the decision taken by Judge C.C. Amerasinghe a Sri Lankan in my civil suit little did he know that the Nigerian President of the Court of Appeal and his two assistant judges from Ghana and Mauritius were guests of the Respondent living in his luxurious Hotel and Resorts in Seychelles where they were well provided for by the Respondent.  Daily contact between the Respondent and the Justice of the Court were unavoidable.  This is a privilege which the appellant did not share with the Respondent.

On the day of the verdict after being served a nice lunch by the Respondent before going to Court, the President of the Court of Appeal and his two assistants who have been regular guests of the Respondent took less than a minute to convince me that I had no case against the Respondent and therefore dismissed my appeal without cost.  That was probably a good thing, at least, to save taxpayer’s money.

I have once witnessed a Referee being suspended for taking part in a Football match because he had been seen talking to a player of the other side before the match.

There are laws that all umpires have to comply with, I don’t see why these laws are not applied in our Judiciary.  In my case I believe that the Court of Appeal failed to abide to their Code of Ethics.

The big question that I have been asking myself is; did the President of the Court of Appeal and his two assistants take the trouble to preside over my appeal or did they come to court with the verdict which was to be in favour of the Respondent before presiding on the appeal case. It is for your readers to ponder upon…..

Injustice never goes stale when the situation gets better and the credibility of our Justice System is in the hands of our indigenous Seychellois.  I may one day be granted a new trial.  I will patiently wait for that to come.

A victim of justice

Your heritage is for sale to make a few people rich

SIR, I am a regular visitor to Seychelles over many years.  My favorite island has always been Silhouette.  It had a feeling of history with its old planter’s house, the tomb, the old cemetery and the small village of Seychelles people and no motor vehicles.

My heart was broken and I will never visit Silhouette again after my recent visit to that once beautiful island.  The quiet Lodge is now replaced by a huge hotel that looks like a housing estate and a large apartment block is being built right on the beach as well as a big souvenir shop and diving center.  Next to the tortoise farm a big group of apartment buildings are being built right on the beach.  Who could have given permission for such buildings right on the beach?

Seychelles  has a good reputation for protecting the environment but on Silhouette it seems that the history and beauty of the island are all to be destroyed for money.

The most terrible news for Silhouette that I heard is the plan to build road right through the jungle right over the top of the mountain to the other side for another new hotel.  How can the reputation of Seychelles as protector of the environment be true if this Treasure Island with its history and incredible jungle is sacrificed to a few rich businessmen?  Already the history is gone and now the jungle.  Your heritage is for sale to make a few people rich.

From a friend of Seychelles

November 2, 2007
Copyright 2007: Seychelles Weekly, Victoria, Mahe, Seychelles